Psychotherapy notes vs progress notes when an AI scribe is in the room

The ScribeMD Team ·

If you use an AI scribe in therapy sessions, the note it drafts is almost always a progress note, not a psychotherapy note. Under HIPAA, psychotherapy notes are the therapist's own separate notes about the conversation, and they get extra protection only when they are kept apart from the rest of the record. A summary of symptoms, interventions and the plan is excluded from that definition by name. So decide before the session what the scribe will capture, where its recording and transcript will live, and which of your thoughts stay out of it. This guide covers the rule, a worked example, a setup checklist and a consent script.

What HIPAA calls psychotherapy notes

The HIPAA Privacy Rule defines psychotherapy notes as "notes recorded (in any medium) by a health care provider who is a mental health professional documenting or analyzing the contents of conversation during a private counseling session or a group, joint, or family counseling session and that are separated from the rest of the individual's medical record" (45 CFR 164.501).

The same definition lists what never counts: "medication prescription and monitoring, counseling session start and stop times, the modalities and frequencies of treatment furnished, results of clinical tests, and any summary of the following items: Diagnosis, functional status, the treatment plan, symptoms, prognosis, and progress to date."

HHS adds one more condition in its guidance: psychotherapy notes "do not include any information that is maintained in a patient's medical record" (HHS FAQ 2088). If your process notes sit in the chart next to the progress note, they lose the special status.

Why the line matters

Most mental health information is treated like any other health information. Psychotherapy notes are the exception, and the differences are large.

  • Authorization. A covered entity "must obtain an authorization for any use or disclosure of psychotherapy notes," with a short list of exceptions, such as use by the therapist who wrote them for treatment (45 CFR 164.508(a)(2)). HHS says this applies even to sharing with another treating provider.
  • Patient access. Patients have a right to inspect and copy their records, except for psychotherapy notes (45 CFR 164.524(a)(1)(i)). HHS notes that providers may still choose to share them, subject to state law.
  • Limits. HHS names exceptions for disclosures required by other law, "such as for mandatory reporting of abuse, and mandatory 'duty to warn' situations." State laws vary on duty to warn.

HHS explains the reason: these notes "are the personal notes of the therapist that typically are not required or useful for treatment, payment, or health care operations purposes, other than by the mental health professional who created the notes." That is the opposite of what a progress note is for. A progress note supports billing, continuity of care and audits.

Where an AI scribe's output lands

An ambient scribe listens to the session, transcribes it and drafts a note from the transcript. Look at what a typical therapy note template asks for: session times, modality, interventions, symptoms, risk, progress and plan. Every one of those items is on the excluded list above. A scribe draft in that shape is part of the medical record once you sign it, and it is subject to the normal rules for access and disclosure.

The recording and the transcript are a separate question. The Privacy Rule's definition predates ambient scribes and does not mention them. Don't assume a transcript is a protected psychotherapy note just because it records the conversation. Treat the audio and transcript as protected health information, and find out where they are stored, who can reach them and when they are deleted. Your compliance lead or counsel should decide how your practice classifies them.

A worked example

A 53-minute individual CBT session with an adult client who is working on panic attacks.

What belongs in the scribe-drafted progress note

  • Start and stop times, and that the session was individual CBT.
  • Symptoms reported: three panic attacks this week, down from five; avoids the subway.
  • Interventions: reviewed the panic diary, practiced interoceptive exposure, assigned graded exposure homework.
  • Risk: denies suicidal ideation, plan or intent.
  • Progress toward goals and the plan for the next session.

What belongs in separate psychotherapy notes, if you keep them

  • Your working hypothesis about how the client's relationship with a parent shapes the panic.
  • Your reaction to the client during the session and what you want to raise in supervision.
  • Details the client shared that are not needed for treatment or billing, such as the names of people in a story.

The scribe heard all of it. Your job at review is to make sure the progress note contains the first list and not the second. If you want the second list, write it yourself, outside the scribe, and store it apart from the chart.

A setup checklist for therapy practices

  1. Choose ambient or dictation. The American Psychological Association points out that many scribes also have a dictation mode, which "does not require the AI to 'listen in' on a session." You dictate a summary afterward and the tool turns it into a note (APA, Guidance for the evaluation of AI scribes). Some clinicians use ambient mode for intakes and medication visits and dictation for sensitive sessions.
  2. Use a progress note template. Pick the format you already sign. Don't build a template that asks the AI for your private impressions; that puts process material into the record.
  3. Trim before you sign. A draft can carry verbatim quotes and third-party details from the transcript. Cut quotes and third-party details that a reader of the chart does not need.
  4. Keep process notes outside the scribe and the EHR. Paper in a locked drawer or a separate encrypted file both work, as long as they stay separate from the record.
  5. Find out where the audio and transcript go. With a cloud scribe, they are uploaded to the vendor. Ask how long the vendor keeps them, whether you can delete them, and whether they are used to train models.
  6. Plan for couples, family and group sessions. The APA guidance asks whether a tool "can be used when multiple parties are part of a clinical appointment." Every person in the room hears the disclosure and can say no.
  7. Review every note. APA is direct: "You must review AI generated documentation for accuracy and edit as needed prior to signing."

The consent conversation

APA's ethical guidance says psychologists should obtain informed consent "by clearly communicating the purpose, application, and potential benefits and risks of relevant AI tools" (APA, Ethical guidance for AI in professional practice). Its scribe guidance adds: "It is important to develop an informed consent process and documentation policy for the use of AI scribes in your practice."

A short script that covers the points:

"I use a tool that listens to our session and drafts my progress note, so I can pay attention to you instead of typing. The note covers things like symptoms, what we worked on and the plan. I read and correct it before it goes in your record. My private notes about our conversation are separate and the tool doesn't write them. You can say no now or at any session, and it won't change your care. Would you like me to use it today?"

Add one sentence on where the recording goes, and make sure it is true for your tool. Write the client's answer in the record, and ask again if the client seems hesitant later.

If you want the recording to stay in the office

Where the audio goes is the hardest part of the consent conversation with a cloud scribe. ScribeMD Desktop in Local only mode runs speech-to-text and note writing on your own computer. The conversation is transcribed as you talk, the note is written when you stop, and visits are kept encrypted on that computer only. Nothing is sent to ScribeMD or to a cloud AI company. It runs on Mac and Windows, includes a Progress note template, and is free for individual doctors with no account needed. For a group practice that wants one machine for every therapist, Cortex runs the scribe on a box on your own network.

Running locally does not change the HIPAA definition. You still review the draft, keep process notes separate and get consent. It does make the answer to "where does this go?" shorter: it stays on this computer.

Where to start

Write a one-page policy this week. Say which sessions use ambient mode and which use dictation, which template you use, where process notes live, and the consent script. Then try it on five sessions with clients who agree, and read each draft against the two lists in the worked example above. If you also document mental status exams, our guide to the mental status exam covers how to document that part of the session.